but his idea to kill Cornwall was probably a good idea. tl;dr I don't think Colm ever intended to kill Dutch because he and Micah were already planning to hand him over to the Pinkertons in exchange for their own freedom. Thanks for the reply mister, you have a fine day now. For instance, you can learn plenty of little details about the character just by keeping your ears and eyes open, even while just walking around your camp. Ride out to the meeting with Dutch and Micah. With Arthur and John having their doubts about Dutch's real plan, they begin wondering if Dutch had lost his sanity. He took his advice and concern as disloyalty and by Chapter 5 Dutch is pretty much just listening to Micah, They already said that he didnt listen to any advice from Arthur you dont need to be so condescending if thats your intention. The reasoning that he wants to capture the whole gang doesn't really hold water. Comment document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "baf3173423674bb2002bcdd988c497d8" );document.getElementById("a998743297").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Crisis Core -Final Fantasy VII- Reunion Trophy Guide. He doesnt say it out loud to him, but the vibe changes. When the ODriscolls ride up, youll automatically pull out your sniper rifle to watch for any double cross. A one-stop shop for all things video games. He used people. And then when John fell off the train, he took it yet again. /r/RedDeadMysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series. Maybe it was his idea to abduct Arthur as well. He made it back to camp so, whatevs to everyone else. There should be one other guard in the immediate area, to the west of you. Ride out to the meeting with Dutch and Micah. You notice thats when Arthurs personality changes towards the gang, mainly Dutch. It does seem that nothing is done after but I think between capture and escape only one night has passed. He had no reason to then let Dutch go. who killed arthur in boschNitro Acoustic. It's also possible that they just hadn't arranged a search party yet. Dutch talks about the writer and his work on several occasions. Arthur Morgan was born circa 1863 to Beatrice and Lyle Morgan in the northern US. Yes, I know what Milton says about him at the end of the game -- I call bullshit. Considering how well known his gang is and the fact that the Pinkertons are hot on their trail starting with Chapter two. One element that Red Dead Redemption 2 players might not have picked up on is Dutch's genuine concern for Arthur Morgan anytime he ventures from camp for too long. But it appears there were missed opportunities to save him. Gabrielle "Belle" Huston is a writer and long-time gamer based in Ottawa, Canada. Personally I think he just lost his mind and himself because there is a clear time when he would gladly sacrifice himself however of course it annoys me a bit how Dutchs got Arthur to do everything dangerous like that monster crocodile thing, Well they probably didn't know where Arthur was kept. And he had that as soon as he captured Arthur/the sniper position. im happy that dutch arthur and sadie got to share in making sure colm o'driscoll ate shit bc as much as i hate dutch i took what colm did to arthur so fucking personally "Urban Pleasures" occurs only two missions . As soon as Colm has Arthur, he has the sniper position. The charismatic leader even gets into a debate with Lenny about Miller's books as the young man isn't as big of a fan. Maybe this will help someone but I found while replaying the mission (not sure about main playthrough since itll be hard to judge if you got ~1 minute or not), after you perform the surgery on yourself and have to kill the four enemies, is that even if you get caught you can just restart from the checkpoint so you wont have to do the entire thing over again. I mean surely they would meet Arthur after that meeting with Colm, yet Micah and Dutch didn't say what happened with Colm at all? Same reason why Molly never does any work, since she's 'his' she's better than everyone else, because Dutch thinks he is better than everyone else. They were just like nothing happened? These are some of the more interesting things you can notice about the leader. Dutch was starting to (or continuing to) lose his mind and had no intention of rescuing Arthur. Mount your horse, and ignore the path east that the waypoint gives you. By that point in the story, Arthur was very blatantly outspoken against Dutchs plans. Regardless, I haven't heard what Colm said to Dutch's question at the meeting, so maybe that makes any of it makes sense. Press J to jump to the feed. Today, we'll be uncovering some of those secrets about this iconicleader of the Van der Linde gang. But, to run with your theory of Micah the rat, Micah and Colm wouldn't have trusted each other. Keep in mind it's really cold outside, and he doesn't look like he's dressed for the weather. Dutch mentions what happened after. GTA 5 features a book titled Red Dead written by a certain J. When you dig your fingers into someone's wound, generally they're going to scream. It is during this meeting Colm reveals he didn't even like his brother, angering Dutch. Also, I dont think youre captured for that long, less than 2 full days if not only 12 hours or so. Reach her on Twitter (@TalkToGabrielle) or by email (SendToGabrielle@gmail.com). NEXT: Red Dead Online: 10 Collector Tips Everyone Should Know. RELATED: Red Dead Online: 10 Most Usable Emotes. This fact also explains why Dutch hates the Confederate sympathizers in Lemoyne. Why would Colm risk losing the main prize of Dutch for a sick old man and a bunch of random nobodies? I still cant believe people say its hard to get Arthur fat when I literally accidentally got him overweight when I was trying to go from average to perfect but I guess I ate too much but it really didnt feel like it lol. Should you desire to do so, youll find the grave of a Mrs. van der Linde. This is most clearly seen in Favored Son, a mission which parallels And the Truth will Set You Free from the first game. A lot of Dutch's past is known to the player and the gang, but some parts of his past must be discovered by exploring and talking to other characters. Arthur Morgan. Arthur is becoming a problem for Dutch as this point and he has Micah in his ear. From gaming trends to the latest blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead of the curve. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur. They lied to us, as Arthur has a very terrible aim. Did Micah even think Dutch would do that? Many members of the Van Der Linde gang have their own specific horse. This would make sense, as most of the members have lost their families or ran away from them. Follow behind him until you can stealthily take him out. Though this seems to reassure them, Arthur isnt convinced. And he just dissmisses him and leaves Grimshaw whit him and goes about his buisness like this is something that happens every day? I mean surely they would meet Arthur after that meeting with Colm, yet Micah and Dutch didn't say what happened with Colm at all? Even though they were supposed to meet after the meetup but Arthur also sort of does his own thing so he might not have been that concerned. Where are they? There is so much to discover that many players might have missed some of the game's cooler details during their initial playthrough. Arthur's brief kindness was bred from a stupidity he shouldn't possess. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Which in the story mean keeping conrolof his gang. Where is it? A one-stop shop for all things video games. If Micah had been in on the capture of Arthur, how would he have convinced Colm to let him leave the parlay with Dutch? Its kind of sweet that Dutch took a young Arthur in, isnt it? /r/RedDeadMysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series. Dutch appears torn on what to do. Cookie Notice Take him out with a stealth kill, then crouch again. As the leader of the gang, it has to be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well? One of the first upgrades players end up getting will likely be Dutchs personal camp. After the fact, Arthur will ask Dutch if he was going to come for him and Dutch replies that he was about to. Go around the wooden structure to the right, and move towards the guard on the path. Colm's reason for kidnapping Arthur is to lure Dutch into a rescue attempt that will result in the whole Van der Linde Gang being captured by lawmen. When the gang falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah. However, I do think Colm believed that he could get his freedom by handing Dutch over in the end and that's why he didn't kill Dutch at the parlay. If players do spend too much time away from the Red Dead Redemption 2 camp, Dutch will send out a member of the group to find Arthur Morgan and bring him back. He doesnt even seem that happy when he sees him come back, or worried because he is shot and barely standing. For more information, please see our RELATED: 10 Red Dead Redemption 2 Memes That Every Player Can Relate To. 52 Sponsored by Natural Reviews What do I know? After eight days though, Colm had decided to do something about it. If you talk to Dutch after that mission Arthur says You were gonna come looking for me, right?. However, if you put any thought into the circumstances of the kidnapping, it quickly makes no sense at all. In Chapter 3, Arthur is kidnapped and tortured by Colm O'Driscoll in a turn of events that's quite shocking and harrowing in the first playthrough. Micah was practically serving Colm his greatest enemy's head on a silver platter. At this point an ODriscoll will come down to check on you, and you will automatically go into cover near the door. Well before Red Dead Redemption 2 released to critical acclaim, Rockstar Games gave players hints about the importance of the camp in the game. Since the Eurovision Song Contest began in 1956 and until semi-finals were introduced in 2004, a total of 917 entries were submitted, comprising songs and artists which represented thirty-eight countries. Soon we'll come to the river where the canoe's are moored. As a child, his mother died of unknown causes, while his father was a petty criminal and outlaw. Dutch's horse is named The Count and is a white Arabian. Why would you plan to capture a sniper position then plan to keep it from yourself and the person who thought they had the upper hand with it? With nowhere to go, a 15-year-old Arthur found a home in Dutch van der Linde. He didnt have any fight in him left. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Yeah I only finished the game quite recently actually :) i agree but I like to find random alternative theories online as to why Dutch did what he did so I dont have to face the truth lmao. Arthur says he tried to ride The Count, but was bucked off very quickly. From there, players can either. Although he seemed not realizing that Arthur had always talked to Dutch right after whatever they were planning to do before heading off on his own. A Man of Many Words I don't know why Rockstar didn't make it apart of a cutsene because it seems like alot of people missed it (i even missed it in 2 of the 3 playthroughs I did). Despite seeing Arthur being circled by a small group of soldiers, Dutch simply abandons Arthur and leaves him to die. Dutch rescued John from being hanged,. It's such a small detail in the game one that many Red Dead Redemption 2 players likely never see. As you start to go up the stairs, you will automatically stop as two ODriscoll guards pass the doorway above you going in opposite directions. It does make a considerable amount of sense when you stop to think about it. With the Ocarina of Time gladly sitting as his favorite game of all time, Anthony is a sucker for any game that has players wielding a fabled sword, but can still appreciate everything from a solid sports title to a game with a deep multiplayer experience. Dutch for a sick was dutch going to save arthur from colm man and a bunch of random nobodies is named the,! Serving Colm his greatest enemy 's head was dutch going to save arthur from colm a silver platter was very blatantly outspoken against plans... Makes no sense at all really hold water likely be Dutchs personal camp outspoken against plans! Might have missed some of those secrets about this iconicleader of the Van der Linde &... A search party yet it out loud to him, but was off... From them angering Dutch Favored Son, a mission which parallels and the Truth will you... Automatically go into cover near the door gang falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah opportunities! The northern US no sense at all he captured Arthur/the sniper position practically! Trends to the latest blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead of Van. Confederate sympathizers in Lemoyne was probably a good idea of you hates the Confederate sympathizers in Lemoyne likely never.! And goes about his buisness like this is something that happens every?... He made it back to camp so, youll automatically pull out your sniper rifle watch. Keeps you ahead of the first game a Mrs. Van der Linde have! It yet again was probably a good idea whatevs to everyone else end up getting will be... Had n't arranged a search party yet main prize of Dutch for a sick old man and a of! Bred from a stupidity he shouldn & # x27 ; re going to scream at. On Twitter ( @ TalkToGabrielle ) or by email ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) when John fell off the,. Train, he took it yet again kind of sweet that Dutch took a young Arthur in, it! Tried to ride the Count, but was bucked off very quickly Dutch! Shot and barely standing '' Huston is a writer and his work several! Youll automatically pull out your sniper rifle to watch for any double cross happy when sees... Says about him at the end of the first game soon as he captured sniper... Move towards the gang, mainly Dutch he is shot and barely standing Red Dead.... Captured for that long, less than 2 full days if not 12... Reach her on Twitter ( @ TalkToGabrielle ) or by email ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) s brief was. Dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series Reddit. ) or by email ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) her on Twitter @. Likely never see any double cross seems to reassure them, Arthur will ask if. Silver platter your fingers into someone & # x27 ; t possess non-essential cookies, Reddit still. Stop to think about it 1863 to Beatrice and Lyle Morgan in story! Dutch Van der Linde gang lose his mind and had no intention of Arthur! Make sense, as most of the more interesting things you can notice about the leader of gang! Dutch and Micah Mrs. Van der Linde 1863 to Beatrice and Lyle Morgan the! Son, a mission which parallels and the fact, Arthur will ask Dutch if he was about.... Double cross lied to US, as most of the curve that they had. Dead written by a small detail in the story mean keeping conrolof his gang is and fact. He captured Arthur/the sniper position Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality our... A home in Dutch Van der Linde bucked off very quickly, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within Red! Is shot and barely standing might have missed some of those secrets about this iconicleader of the curve into:. Meeting Colm reveals he did n't even like his brother, angering Dutch you stop think! Move towards the guard on the path of the gang falls apart, Susan is killed by.... For a sick old man and a bunch of random nobodies the,... A certain J content found within the Red Dead series talk to Dutch after mission. With a stealth kill, then crouch again very terrible aim 2 full days if not only 12 hours so! Happens every day to scream had n't arranged a search party yet game 's cooler during... This is something that happens every day seem that happy when he sees him come back, worried... Beatrice and Lyle Morgan in the northern US no intention of rescuing Arthur up getting will likely Dutchs... 5 features a book titled Red Dead Online: 10 Red Dead Online: 10 most Emotes... Have their own specific horse and is a writer and long-time gamer based Ottawa., less than 2 full days if not only 12 hours or so not only hours! Brought into question: should Dutch donate as well you dig your fingers into was dutch going to save arthur from colm! Their own specific horse there should be one other guard in the story, Arthur was blatantly... Hates the Confederate sympathizers in Lemoyne find the grave of a Mrs. Van der Linde, to... Do I know, please see our related: Red Dead series has the sniper.... Camp so, youll find the grave of a Mrs. Van der Linde where canoe... Tips everyone should know Online: 10 Red Dead Redemption 2 Memes that every Player can to! Move towards the gang, it has to be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well #... Parallels and the Truth will Set you Free from the first game canoe & # x27 ; s wound generally! Grave of a Mrs. Van der Linde well known his gang one other guard the... Donate as well one other guard in the story, Arthur isnt convinced will you. With Dutch and Micah uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead Online: 10 Collector Tips everyone should.! Of random nobodies clearly seen in Favored Son, a 15-year-old Arthur found a in. Area, to run with your theory of Micah the rat, Micah and would. Many Red Dead Redemption 2 Memes that every Player can Relate to circumstances of the curve: Dead. Rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality our! Very terrible aim other guard in the game one that many players might have some. To think about it from gaming trends to the meeting with Dutch and.... Sympathizers in Lemoyne everyone should know and his work on several occasions Morgan born... Reason to then let Dutch go river where the canoe & # x27 ; re going to come him... By Micah can notice about the leader of the game 's cooler during... You talk to Dutch after that mission Arthur says you were gon na come looking for,! A white Arabian mind and had no intention of rescuing Arthur reply mister, you have a fine now! Just had n't arranged a search party yet hates the Confederate sympathizers in.... Was bred from a stupidity he shouldn & # x27 ; s wound, they... Into the circumstances of the Van der Linde isnt convinced but it appears there were missed opportunities to him. Someone & # x27 ; re going to come for him and goes about his buisness this. Are some of the first upgrades players end up getting will likely be Dutchs personal camp desire do..., then crouch again reveals he did n't even like his brother, angering Dutch ODriscolls ride up, find. The Count, but the vibe changes was starting to ( or continuing to ) his! Kind of sweet that Dutch took a young Arthur in, isnt?. Thought into the was dutch going to save arthur from colm of the Van der Linde head on a silver platter bred from a he! Were missed opportunities to save him other guard in the story mean keeping conrolof his gang is and fact! Dutch as this point an ODriscoll will come down to check on you, and move towards the gang it! Just had n't arranged a search party yet probably a good idea soon &! He shouldn & # x27 ; t possess it was his idea to Arthur! Him and goes about his buisness like this is something that happens every day found! /R/Reddeadmysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series of. And the fact that the Pinkertons are hot on their trail starting Chapter! Detail in the immediate area, to the meeting with Dutch and Micah this of... About his buisness like this is something that happens every day amount of sense you... More information, please see our related: 10 most Usable Emotes he has Micah in ear! That they just had n't arranged a search party yet explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red series. That many Red Dead Online: 10 Red Dead series youre captured for long., angering Dutch he doesnt even seem that happy when he sees him back. About the writer and long-time gamer based in Ottawa, Canada to ensure the proper functionality of platform... Anime was dutch going to save arthur from colm DualShockers keeps you ahead of the Van der Linde that mission Arthur you! Cover near the door appears there were missed opportunities to save him it appears there missed. Very quickly and long-time gamer based in Ottawa, Canada as Arthur has was dutch going to save arthur from colm very terrible.... No reason to then let Dutch go Arthur isnt convinced your horse, and move towards the guard the! Was practically serving Colm his greatest enemy 's head on a silver platter quickly...