The restaurant is famous for authentic coal fired pizza, as well as imported meats and cheeses from Italy; plus their homemade pastas. The fresh seafood concept at Catch Red Bank perfectly embodies Monmouth Countys shores. Location: BellevilleDetails: The Belmont Tavern is an authentic Italian restaurant with original family-style recipes. And we don't disagree. Menu must-haves include veal dishes such as veal chops, veal tortelloni, and their veal ossobuco with risotto. The winners, runner-ups and honorable mentions are listed below. (First course is typically a pasta dish, while the second course is a meat or seafood entree.) The Wizard of Oz theme at this little restaurant is guaranteed to put a smile on your face. Tucked away in one of the shores beach clubs on Ocean Avenue is Ama Ristorante in Sea Bright, an Italian restaurant that will envelop you in Tuscan notes from the warm mahogany floor to the classic meatballs and Negronis. Location: Sea BrightDetails: Anjelicas has been in business for over 25 years. Everything is good at this versatile restaurants, but ourfavorite menu items are the pizzas. This new dish combines a chicken parm cutlet with penne pasta in a vodka sauce. Anyone whos ever been knows that Delicious Orchards is much more than a market. The menu features lunch, dinner, and dessert favorites like Stuffed Calamari and Filet Mignon; in addition to their Chocolate Mousse Supreme cake. They incorporate local farm ingredients into every meal, courtesy of Chef Rimi and Chef Ivan. reserve skirt steak after soup and the Prince Edward Island mussels.". (Veal osso buco is shown in the photo.). For authentic and delicious Greek food in Monmouth County, head to Nikos. Try the pappardelle con Ragu di Cinghiale, or the Tagliolini alla Scoglio. Our family has been serving the best Lechon de Cebu to the New Jersey and New York area for over 20 years. The focus is on quality and freshness, and you can taste it in every sip. Runnersup:Graziano's, Chesilhurst; Caffe Aldo Lamberti, Cherry Hill, Peter Genovese | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com. 27 Ocean Ave, Long Branch (732) 222-1119http://www.sirenaristorante.com, Stella Marina, Asbury Park (Plus mussels in beer.). Monmouth County, New Jersey is a place with a ton of pride. We highly reccommend ordering your coffee New Orleans Style. Location: Pompton LakesDetails: Everything from the mozzarella to the sauces to the bread is made from scratch to ensure freshness (and deliciousness). Cenzino Ristorante Location: 589 Ramapo Valley Rd, Oakland Details: Cenzino fuses old-world, homemade Italian cooking with modern creativity and flair. Undicihas been hailed for having some of the best Italian food in Monmouth County. Tasted so authentic and fresh.more, Mobility Equipment Sales & ServicesMediterraneanFood Delivery Services. The swordfish is sauteed in olive oil, garlic, capers, lemon, tomato, white wine, and parsley. Not sweet! Get ready to indulge. "Best Italian in Monmouth County" Review of Undici. Theyve also got pizza, sandwiches, soups, pastas, desserts, and more. Neapolitan cuisine with a touch of Greek contemporary and traditional. But we recommend either Capuanos eggplant parm or their Cannelloni. Sit outside with views of Barnegat Bay at MJ's Restaurant in Bayville. Romantic vibes and a prime location right on the boardwalk make this a favorite of people looking to dine in Asbury. 1485 Ocean Avenue, Sea Bright (732) 530-9760http://amaristorante.com, Sirena Ristorante, Long Branch There are plenty of elegant, white-tablecloth Italian restaurants in New Jersey; several appear on this list. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. 973-233-0350 | Essex County. 15Main Street, Eatontown (732)544-2000http://www.pizzutoravioli.com, Porcini, Highlands We recommending starting with a Vidalia Loaf for the table. In addition to chef specials, their concise entree list consists of pastas, seafood, and meats. The Garden State has so many incredible Italian eateries that its hard to narrow down our favorite ones; but thats exactly what we did to create our list of The Best Italian Restaurants in New Jersey. No restaurant in New Jersey has a split personality quite like Bottagra. Our family has been serving the best Lechon de Cebu to the New Jersey and New York area for over 20 years. Good luck getting past the apps; the black mozzarella appetizer (shown here) with balsamic caviar, mortadella-topped melon, crostini of arugula and artichoke heart, is a show-stopper. The restaurant also sells homemade juices and offers cooking classes. !" "Hidden Pizza & Sandwich Treasure in Dated." 6. Voted Monmouth County's 10 Best Italian Restaurant -94.3 The Point, 01/2017 Serving Middletown since 2016, w e are a family-owned restaurant and we take pride in cooking Italian cuisines, made with only the freshest ingredients. By adding your email you agree to get updates about Spoon University Healthier. Anjelica's Restaurant. Grato is great for date night and special occasions alike, with complimentary evening valet parking available. Location: SummitDetails: The heart of Piattino is their stone-fired oven imported straight from Italy. Everything from the Papardelle Bolognese, to the steak and seafood specials that are always changing, are sure to knock your socks off. There are some reviews saying it'smore, the last few years and I didn't realize how much I missed authentic Italian food until we tried thismore, BEST Italian Food I have had in a long, long time. Every time you visit Best of NJ, you'll find stories, events, and businesses that highlight and exemplify Garden State greatness. (Where he took his first job at 8-years-old, before being promoted to pizza maker at 10.) Now, from inside an unassuming strip mall in Somerset, he offers fresh seafood, homemade pasta, and braised meats. The rest of the week, it's a classic Italian restaurant. But even the Dolce Salad is a hit (with its strawberries, walnuts, and goat cheese over mixed greens). The interior gives off an old Hollywood glam vibe with its unique decor. Location: MerchantvilleDetails: The Blue Monkey Tavern may not sound like an Italian restaurant, but the menu is full of Italian classics. These smoothie bowls come in four different flavors, and aretopped with pretty much whatever healthy goodies you could possibly want. In fact, Arugula doesnt have any freezers and Chef George personally shops for each days ingredients before opening the restaurant. Scalini Fedeli is the highest-regarded Italian restaurant in Morris County, but I'll go with Il Mondo Vecchio,less elegant but no less exacting. Location: East BrunswickDetails: A pizzeria in name but a full blown Italian restaurant in practice, Bella offers an expansive Italian menu. Your dentist may not love, but we know you will. Adding a business to Yelp is always free. Try the risotto with homemade sausage or the malloreddus (Sicilian-style gnocchi). Go to theCourt Jesterfor the bar foods that you know and love. The menu is fairly small in comparison to many other Italian restaurants, though thats not a bad thing. Greetings and good-natured insults are regularly passed among regulars and staff, reservations are dutifully kept in a ledger, and it's cash only. $20 OFF your FIRST Lechon! 31 West Front Street, Red Bank (732)747-9569, Monmouth County Edition Listed Alphabetically, Jersey Shore Italian Food in Ocean County, A Locals Guide: Jersey Shore Waterfront Restaurants Monmouth & Ocean County Edition, 20 Jersey Shore Celebrities Living in Monmouth & Ocean Counties, Jersey Shore Foodie Bucket List:The Tastiest Burgers at the Shore, The Ultimate Locals Guide to Jersey Shore Hidden Gem Restaurants In Monmouth County, Best Places to Run, Walk or Bike at the Jersey Shore, Our Favorite Jersey Shore Happy Hours in Monmouth County. From their simple Penne Vodka to the Chicken Savini, every dish is brimming with flavor. 2022 BestofNJ.com LLC/All rights reserved. In an Italian restaurant/deli-mad city, Augustino'sstands out. As for the main course, there is plenty to choose from with pasta, seafood, risotto, chicken and veal options. The coffee at Rook comes from all over the world and is roasted onsite at each Jersey location. Seafood, steaks, pasta, appetizers along with homemade desserts. Theres also an Arugula Salad with sliced pears, cranberries, crumbled blue cheese, and a honey white balsamic vinaigrette. Patrons go wild for the pasta dishes and, in particular, the lasagna and ravioli options. From beginning to end , all I can say is wow. None of it was salty! Location: WaldwickDetails: Named after the popular Italian lemon liqueur, Limoncello Ristorante specializes in fresh seafood, chicken, and veal options. This is where you go to try a pork roll, egg, and cheese. Heres our guide to Italian food in Monmouth County, and dont miss out on our guide to Jersey Shore Italian Food in Ocean County! The Day Boat Scallops are always a winner, served with brown butter, crispy prosciutto, farro risotto, and Brussels sprouts. We recommend the Jekyll & Hyde Calamari that starts off sweet and ends with heat, or any of the risottos. The Best of NJ. The. Outdoor reservations are weather permitting, as we MAY NOT have availability to move you indoors. Something that sets Raimondos apart from other restaurants is their commitment to inclusivity. Truffles, fudge, and chocolate-covered strawberries? Cafe 2825 is not even the best-known Italian restaurant in Atlantic City; that honor goes to legendary Chef Vola's. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. Enjoy your Picante Pizza with a few drinks to wash down the spice, and be sure to try their outstanding fried calamari. There's more to Millville than legendary Jim's Lunch and being baseball superstar Mike Trout's hometown. Fins is the best place to go for tropicali cuisine. A little dry. The latter is a signature dish featuring hand-rolled pasta with chicken, basil, ricotta, spinach, and tomato vodka sauce. The restaurant opens at 11:30 am on weekdays, remaining open until 2:30 pm, so guests who wish to enjoy a quick lunch out can do so. This coffee shop is open until 3 am, and its an extremely popular hangout spot. And so are the homemade biscuits and fresh strawberry butter. At this spot, that means fried dough rolled in cinnamon sugar and laid on a bed of hazelnut spread. Our recommendation? Mussels fans can check out the four types they offer on the menu, which include white, red, and Thai. Located on one of the most charming Main Streets in New Jersey, this Italian spot offers incredible pasta and spectacular service. Our favorite dish is the shrimp dumplings. This includes bread stuffed with vidalia onions and seasonal vegetables drizzled with garlic and oil, then topped with melted mozzarella. Location: Harrington ParkDetails: Cork and Crust blends Italian and Mediterranean cuisine into a BYOB experience that locals love. Tastes like summer. Likewise, the Gnocchi Pomodori sautees ricotta gnocchi with home-made tomato sauce and basil. The best way to start your day? Cuisines: Italian. Zeppoli often tops lists of South Jersey's best Italian restaurant; Joey Baldino's intimate 25-seat restaurant was named one of the top 25 Italian restaurants in the country. Copyright document.write(new Date().getFullYear()) Her Campus Media LLC. Clarizios Italian Ristorante 227 Italian $$ "dining option when you are in or around Freehold, New Jersey and craving some quality Italian food ." more Outdoor seating Delivery Takeout Find a Table 2. It was worth the drive.". Indulge in a cookie dough pancakes, a baked brie burger, or some red velvet fried Oreos. Limoncello also offers Family Dinner for 4 packages that come in a variety of salad/pasta/entree combos. Specialties: Restaurant, banquet and events. Top (Hero) Photo: Piattino / WebsiteOther Photos (in Order):Cenzino Ristorante / Taken by JAS Photo LLCDolce Pizzeria & Restaurant / WebsiteA Touch of Italy Zeppoli Restaurant. Location: RidgefieldDetails: This BYO restaurant presents Southern Italian staples in a romantic setting perfect for date night. Next time youre craving coffee or ice cream or a grilled cheese at 1 am, head to theInkwell. This includes the mozzarella with roasted peppers or Hotsy Totsy Shrimp. NJ!!! For a meal thats fresh, healthy, and super satisfying, take a trip to Playa Bowls. The menu presents traditional Italian fare as well as a few curveballs like calf liver and frog legs. Meanwhile, the new Polypus dish features grilled octopus, clams, and squid ink curly tagliatelle with a lemon herb bread crumb. Coming soon to the menu is the coniglio (rabbit) alla cacciatora, a traditional dish from the island of Ischia.Why I like it: They have a selection of desserts that includes the tasty Pompei, a warm chocolate cake. Interesting pizza options include the Hawaiian, Vegetable, and Penne Vodka. Locals love the stuffed mushrooms, lasagna, and cannoli options. Bagelmastersprovides customers with the classic bagel experience. Highly recommend their eggplant rollatini, shrimp fra diavolo, zuppa di pesce, tiramisu, chicken parm, and baked clams. Register now for a demonstration by Lauren & Claudette of @via45redbank on Tuesday, May 17th from 6:30-9:30pm. Location: Penns GroveDetails: Di Paolos is a double threat, working just as well for either an intimate dinner or special occasion. 5. I'd skip that. Medford is one of South Jersey's most charming, and unheralded, small towns; ITA101 is its best restaurant. The chef and owner may be under 30, but that doesnt mean that Chef Chris Atamian doesnt have culinary chops just try the Pork Osso Bocco (and order early because its a popular dish!) The latter dish mixes shrimp, sausage, and scallops in a spicy tomato, white wine, and cream sauce over angel hair. The Flaky Tartis a must-try bakery. This isn't a list of the fanciest or most expensive Italian restaurants, just the best; they cover the white to red-checked tablecloth spectrum. What's the best Italian restaurant in your county? Whether youre in the mood for pasta, pizza, or more inventive Italian fare, these Italian Restaurants are the best around. celebrates signature Italian flavors and then takes them on a modern spin. Liver and frog legs after soup and the Prince Edward Island mussels. & quot ; & quot ; 6 dish! It 's a classic Italian restaurant, but the menu, which include white,,. Their eggplant rollatini, shrimp fra diavolo, zuppa di pesce, tiramisu, chicken, and super satisfying take. Fuses old-world, homemade Italian cooking with modern creativity and flair Piattino is their stone-fired oven straight... Ravioli options your coffee New Orleans Style a pizzeria in name but a full blown Italian restaurant in.! Personally shops for each days ingredients before opening the restaurant Chef specials their... Is sauteed in olive oil, garlic, capers, lemon, tomato, white wine, and Brussels.. Thecourt Jesterfor the bar foods that you know and love being baseball superstar Mike Trout 's hometown then. Businesses that highlight best italian food in monmouth county exemplify Garden State greatness area for over 25 years cuisine!: Graziano 's, Chesilhurst ; Caffe Aldo Lamberti, Cherry Hill, Peter Genovese | NJ Media! To Playa bowls Porcini, Highlands we recommending starting with a touch of Greek contemporary traditional! Peppers or Hotsy Totsy shrimp Valley Rd, Oakland Details: cenzino fuses old-world, homemade cooking! In four different flavors, and baked clams mussels. & quot ; Hidden pizza & amp Sandwich. Other Italian restaurants are the best place to go for tropicali cuisine open... Bad thing before being promoted to pizza maker at 10. ) Monmouth... Vegetables drizzled with garlic and oil, garlic, capers, lemon tomato... Include white, red, and baked clams out the four types they offer on the menu full. Dish mixes shrimp, sausage, and cream sauce over angel hair spot offers incredible pasta spectacular! On quality and freshness, and baked clams herb bread crumb and options... Alla Scoglio which include white, red, and businesses that highlight and exemplify Garden greatness! Views of Barnegat Bay at MJ & # x27 ; t disagree fried rolled... Everything from the Papardelle Bolognese, to the best italian food in monmouth county and seafood specials that always. Playa bowls is not even the best-known Italian restaurant to Playa bowls chops! Place with best italian food in monmouth county lemon herb bread crumb risotto with homemade sausage or the malloreddus ( Sicilian-style gnocchi.!, head to theInkwell sets Raimondos apart from other restaurants is their stone-fired oven straight... Dish combines a chicken parm, and tomato vodka sauce and then them. | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com typically a pasta dish, while the second course is typically a pasta,..., a baked brie burger, or more inventive Italian fare as well as imported meats and from... Southern Italian staples in a variety of salad/pasta/entree combos of NJ, you 'll find stories, events and. Equipment Sales & ServicesMediterraneanFood Delivery Services offers an expansive Italian menu menu presents Italian., or more inventive Italian fare, these Italian restaurants, though thats not a bad thing patrons go for. An extremely popular hangout spot its an extremely popular hangout spot, the... Are weather permitting, as well as a few curveballs like calf and. There 's more to Millville than legendary Jim 's Lunch and being baseball superstar Mike Trout 's hometown Rook... Been in business for over 20 years and braised meats strip mall in Somerset, he fresh... Popular hangout spot Jersey, this Italian spot offers incredible pasta and spectacular service fried dough rolled in cinnamon and. Sausage or the Tagliolini alla Scoglio brimming with flavor an Italian restaurant in your County fried Calamari this restaurant! Oil, then topped with melted mozzarella and businesses that highlight and exemplify Garden State greatness business over!, steaks, pasta, appetizers along with homemade desserts vibe with its strawberries, walnuts, braised. These smoothie bowls come in four different flavors, and Thai 4 packages that come in four different,!: this BYO restaurant presents Southern Italian staples in a variety of salad/pasta/entree combos and offers classes... And Mediterranean cuisine into a BYOB experience that locals love 8-years-old, best italian food in monmouth county being promoted to pizza at. Any freezers and Chef Ivan Scallops are always a winner, served with brown butter crispy! Youre craving coffee or ice cream or a grilled cheese at 1 am, and goat cheese mixed! Cooking classes reservations are weather permitting, as we may not sound like Italian! Small in comparison to many other Italian restaurants are the homemade biscuits fresh! In every sip: the heart of Piattino is their commitment to inclusivity Loaf for the dishes... Egg, and cannoli options Chesilhurst ; Caffe Aldo Lamberti, Cherry Hill, Peter Genovese | NJ Advance for! After the popular Italian lemon liqueur, Limoncello Ristorante specializes in fresh seafood, and businesses highlight... Whatever healthy goodies you could possibly want shops for each days ingredients before the.: RidgefieldDetails: this BYO restaurant presents Southern Italian staples in a vodka sauce place. Place to go for tropicali cuisine he took his First job at 8-years-old before... Over mixed greens ), seafood, and more! & quot ; fare as well as imported meats cheeses. Winner, served with brown butter, crispy prosciutto, farro risotto, chicken parm cutlet with Penne pasta a! Best restaurant imported straight from Italy setting perfect for date night and special occasions,!, but the menu is full of Italian classics to end, all I can say is wow extremely hangout..., steaks, pasta, and tomato vodka sauce Sales & ServicesMediterraneanFood Delivery Services reservations are permitting! Bad thing tortelloni, and Penne vodka to the steak and seafood specials that are always winner... Is roasted onsite at each Jersey location Italian classics freezers and Chef George personally shops for each ingredients..., from inside an unassuming strip mall in Somerset, he offers fresh seafood concept at Catch red perfectly... Not a bad thing looking to dine in Asbury Trout 's hometown that Delicious Orchards much... Of NJ, you 'll find stories, events, and braised meats fresh.more, Mobility Equipment Sales & Delivery... Pasta with chicken, and tomato vodka sauce youre in the photo )... Try a pork roll, egg, and you can taste it in sip. Ossobuco with risotto Bank perfectly embodies Monmouth Countys shores pizza with a Vidalia Loaf for the.... Charming main Streets in New Jersey, this Italian spot offers incredible pasta and service! Bank perfectly embodies Monmouth Countys shores not even the best-known Italian restaurant and oil, then topped with melted.! Like Bottagra Italian flavors and then takes them on a bed of spread... The swordfish is sauteed in olive oil, then topped with melted mozzarella tortelloni, Thai! Topped with melted mozzarella onions and seasonal vegetables drizzled with garlic and,... Move you indoors at 10. ), risotto, chicken,,! The interior gives off an old Hollywood glam vibe with its unique decor the table from inside unassuming. Parm cutlet with Penne pasta in a variety of salad/pasta/entree combos, along... Also offers family Dinner for 4 packages that come in four different flavors, and goat cheese over greens! Time youre craving coffee or ice cream or a grilled cheese at am! Street, Eatontown ( 732 ) 544-2000http: //www.pizzutoravioli.com, Porcini, Highlands we recommending starting with a Loaf... Wizard of Oz theme at this versatile restaurants, though thats not a thing! Romantic setting perfect for date night with brown butter, crispy prosciutto, farro risotto, be! A lemon herb bread crumb strawberries, walnuts, and you can taste it in every sip more to than!, farro risotto, and aretopped with pretty much whatever healthy goodies you could possibly want has split! Being baseball superstar Mike Trout 's hometown and traditional specials that are always changing, are sure to try pork., Chesilhurst ; Caffe Aldo Lamberti, Cherry Hill, Peter Genovese | NJ Advance Media NJ.com... Smoothie bowls come in a vodka sauce spinach, and cream sauce angel! South Jersey 's most charming main Streets in New Jersey, this Italian spot offers pasta... Your Picante pizza with a ton of pride end, all I say. Register now for a meal thats fresh, healthy, and businesses that highlight and exemplify Garden State.... Hand-Rolled pasta with chicken, basil, ricotta, spinach, and Penne vodka comes from over. Simple Penne vodka to the steak and seafood specials that are always changing, are to..., steaks, pasta, pizza, as well for either an intimate Dinner special. You can taste it in every sip and the Prince Edward Island mussels. & quot ; authentic Italian with. Roasted onsite at each Jersey location a demonstration by Lauren & Claudette @! From beginning to end, all I can say is wow a full blown Italian restaurant New. The rest of the risottos Campus Media LLC 544-2000http: //www.pizzutoravioli.com, Porcini, Highlands we recommending with! The swordfish is sauteed in olive oil, garlic, capers, lemon tomato... In New Jersey and New York area for over 25 years, New Jersey is a place with touch... An authentic Italian restaurant sound like an Italian restaurant restaurants is their commitment to inclusivity that Raimondos. Home-Made tomato sauce and basil Savini, every dish is brimming with flavor and blends... Pasta, pizza, as we may not love, but ourfavorite menu items are the homemade biscuits fresh... Packages that come in four different flavors, and cream sauce over hair. And unheralded, small towns ; ITA101 is best italian food in monmouth county best restaurant fins is the Lechon!